Indiana Jones and The Great Circle designer explains why the adventure game is so similar to The Chronicles of Riddick: Escape from Butcher Bay

Indiana Jones and The Great Circle - Indy - in front of The Chronicles of Riddick: Escape from Butcher Bay screenshot

Published:

Last Updated: 16 November 2026

By:

MachineGames’ Indiana Jones and The Great Circle is a fantastically immersive first-person shooter. While a unique game for modern gamers, the fairly new adventure game is actually remarkably similar in its design to another movie-based game—The Chronicles of Riddick: Escape from Butcher Bay.

Created by Starbreeze in 2004, Escape from Butcher Bay was cancelled before its release, but the studio managed to finish it anyway. Starring Vin Diesel, the game merged first-person with intercut moments of third-person animation, and it quickly became a cult classic. So much so that its devs are hoping for a remaster, although the source code is sadly lost.

While Riddick himself is likely not coming back for a new game, Indiana Jones and The Great Circle revives many of Starbreeze’s greatest ideas. In an interview on our FRVR Podcast, design director Jens Andersson explained that the new game simply continued the great ideas put forth by the now-22-year-old stealth game.

“The easy answer is that it’s made by a lot of the same people,” Andersson explained. Alongside Andersson himself, who worked as a designer on both games, Indiana Jones’ game director Jerk Gustafsson was the lead designer on Escape from Butcher Bay. Both games share an inherent design that pushes for immersion, and both games cut between first and third-person.

“You start redoing all these kinds of design thoughts and processes, and that’s why you end up with cubes as a health meter.”

Indiana Jones and The Great Circle design director Jens Andersson

“We still have the same taste as we did 20 years ago,” Andersson continued. “But that in combination with the process, right? We start with Indiana Jones, you look at what is that? What is the story I want to tell? What is the gameplay that we want to have in this game?”

He continued: “It’s very interesting because looking at Indiana Jones as a matinee action adventure, the feature set is very similar to what we ended up with in Riddick. Like, obviously, there must be some sort of melee combat. Obviously, there needs to be some traversal. We like the adventure; he’s the original adventurer, right? There must be adventure elements.”

Andersson explained that “a lot of these features naturally overlapped” and the team never “shied away from the comparison”. While MachineGames is known for its work on Wolfenstein, that balls-to-the-wall action isn’t the only thing the team wants to create, and Indiana Jones was a way to once again experiment with the thrilling gameplay they designed as Starbreeze for Riddick.

“We didn’t need to stay away from it,” he continued. “We could be proud of it that, ‘Oh, we did that in Riddick and it worked well. Let’s do that again.’ So, I think that’s the main reason [they’re so similar].”

When Indiana Jones and the Great Circle was first announced, many were upset that the game was designed as a first-person adventure. It’s a bold move; while more immersive, locking a player into first-person for the bulk of gameplay means you don’t get to see the iconic character players have bought the game for.

“When MachineGames were approached about doing Indiana Jones, that was the starting point. It’s the first-person studio. I’m sure they would be able to pull off amazing games in other perspectives as well, but that’s their expertise and that’s what they love,” he said.

The comparisons between Riddick and Indiana Jones—the games, not movies—are plentiful, and that simply comes down to the tastes of the team. The way that combat functions is similar to Riddick, the way that the game cuts to third-person for platforming is similar, and even the cube-based health bars are similar.

“How does a first-person Indiana Jones game look? Oh, well it looks like first-person, and we love immersion, everyone loves immersion, we are good at doing immersion,” Andersson continued. “And so you start redoing all these kind of design thoughts and processes, and that’s why you end up with cubes as a health meter. Well, that one in particular, I don’t know. That’s because we like it.”

While over two-decades removed, Indiana Jones and The Great Circle and The Chronicles of Riddick: Escape from Butcher Bay are sibling games. Indy’s design is intrinsically linked to the horrifically underrated 2004 stealth game, although obviously much more advanced. Few games are like Riddick and Indy, and it’s incredible to see the design language of the 2004 game continue through MachineGames’ latest release.