Former Id Software developers have revealed that there was a “contingent” of DOOM developers that wanted to work on Halo following Xbox’s acquisition of the studio.
Following layoffs at Id Software, which cut the iconic game studio in half, a small group of DOOM devs have founded new indie studio Hidden Horses. In an upcoming FRVR Podcast episode to discuss the new studio and its upcoming Kickstarter, former producer Andrew Willis and principal programmer Dustin Land revealed that multiple developers at Id Software wanted the opportunity to work on Halo.
While there were never any official plans to work on the Halo franchise, developers at Id wanted to make a Halo game after seeing the state of the franchise after Halo Infinite.
“For us, it was just seeing it, a year ago or longer than that,” Willis told us. “Just seeing it struggle. Nobody was like: ‘Oh, I’m designing X or it could be this. Or I’m making a model.’”
Willis explained that multiple people at Id Software wanted the studio to be handed the keys to the Halo franchise. “It was just people talking like, ‘they should give that to us. We could do an awesome job.’ And I think it just, the way we built shooters with a focus on crazy sci-fi weapons with all kinds of crazy mechanics and stuff, there was just a contingent.”
Land explained that it “never went beyond just fanboying ourselves”, and Willis explained that “not everyone” wanted that. However, as Id joined the Xbox umbrella, working on the Halo franchise became a possibility, or at least more of a possibility than prior to the acquisition.
“That was one of the things at the acquisition like, ‘we’re under the same roof, so maybe there could be a collab’. To Andrew’s point, it was like, well, if they’re going to be giving it to someone else, it would be fun if we could do it. But nothing official ever came of it.”
It’s undeniable that the Halo franchise was suffering. While Land explained that they really enjoy Halo Infinite and had a couple of discussions with 343/Halo Studios’ tech team, the release of Campaign Evolved and the shift to Unreal Engine was a sign that things weren’t going well.
Land explained that it did make sense overall to move to Unreal Engine as more people are familiar with it in the industry. However, they explained that when studios move away from their established pipelines, it’s usually a sign that something else is wrong.
“I’m always a little surprised when a studio abandons their engine or tech. It’s usually not a healthy sign for a studio. But it’s like, tech is really more of a loss centre these days. It’s hard to make that business argument that there’s actually value in it,” Land explained, adding that Unity and Epic’s main income doesn’t even come from engine licensing anymore.
Right now, the Halo IP is going through another landmine with the IP moving over to a new studio under Activision. Even Halo Studios’ narrative team, which handled the series’ successful cross-media releases, has been gutted, and there are rumours that the series will be rebooted.
As for Hooded Horses, the studio filled with Id Software alumni is working on a brand-new indie FPS game. Currently in very early stages, the core idea for the game should be revealed later this year as the team looks to Kickstarter for fan support. While generational talent has been cut from Id, at least some of those developers already have great ideas for brand-new games.



